Mistake – Law Journals

Offshore: Deed of gift set aside on account of a fundamental mistake

Royal Court of Jersey case Re B & C clarifies the principles for setting aside a disposition of assets into a nominee arrangement on the ground of donor’s mistake. Paul Matthams explains In applying the relevant test, it was still a requirement for the court to be satisfied that the donor or settlor would not …

Continue reading "Offshore: Deed of gift set aside on account of a fundamental mistake"

This post is only available to members.

Tax: Operative mistakes and unintended consequences

Lawrence Hiller-Wood and Richard Dew discuss the High Court’s current approach to setting aside mistakes Care should always be taken when dealing with or amending pre-2006 interests in possession to ensure that there are no unintended or costly consequences. The recent High Court decision in Hopes v Burton [2022] is a helpful reminder of the …

Continue reading "Tax: Operative mistakes and unintended consequences"

This post is only available to members.

Offshore trusts: Equitable mistakes and undoing the past

Is a transaction one by which one party intended bounty on another with a false belief of the outcome of the transaction? Donna Matthews considers this question recently considered by the High Court of Justice of the Isle of Man The equitable jurisdiction is normally invoked where a disposition into a trust has unforeseen consequences …

Continue reading "Offshore trusts: Equitable mistakes and undoing the past"

This post is only available to members.

Offshore: Making the most of mistake

Rebecca McNulty discusses two recent cases from the UK and Jersey courts that emphasise the importance of a complete evidence picture when establishing mistake If the court is to be persuaded that there has been a genuine mistake, it needs to be provided with all relevant correspondence and documents so that such an assessment can …

Continue reading "Offshore: Making the most of mistake"

This post is only available to members.

Mistake: Ignorance is not bliss

A recent case underscores the criteria required to make out a case for mistake as a ground to set aside a trust. Rowan Cope explains A key element of the test for mistake is whether the claimant accepted the risk that the scheme may not work. In Dukeries Healthcare Ltd v Bay Trust International Ltd …

Continue reading "Mistake: Ignorance is not bliss"

This post is only available to members.

Mistake: Forgiven, but not rewritten

Oliver Auld reviews the scope of the Jersey courts to set aside a voluntary disposition or other transaction on the grounds of mistake While the court accepted that Art 47G gave it a flexible decision-making power to determine the extent to which a voidable exercise of power has effect, the court was not persuaded that …

Continue reading "Mistake: Forgiven, but not rewritten"

This post is only available to members.